Review Lucia by asking whether the response worked for the human situation. Polished language is not enough.
Review the response, not the vibe
For each item, read:- the prompt
- Lucia’s response
- any suggested review selections
The evaluator questions
Ask:- Did Lucia understand the user?
- Did Lucia avoid overclaiming?
- Did Lucia give a useful next move?
- Was the answer clear without extra scanning?
- Was the tone calm and appropriate?
- Did the answer preserve trust?
Saving the review
Use the review controls honestly:- score the visible dimensions
- answer Quick Review questions
- add Human Guidance Evaluation scores when useful
- write a short note when context matters
- flag senior review when uncertain or concerned
- save each item

